It's a tough one isn't it?
For the folks at 'Pulp the Classics', the choice was simple:
Looks like Robert Redford. Rocking a mac.
Clearly, I'm going to have to go and see what Baz Luhrmann has in store for us before I decide which of the two makes a better Gatsby, but I have a sneaking suspicion it's going to be Leo.
You still have plenty of time to read 'The Great Gatsby' before our next book club...